Some of Florida’s DUI laws may be unconstitutional

A recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling is throwing doubt on the constitutionality of some Florida DUI laws.

A recent ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court concerning Minnesota’s DUI laws could have a significant impact on the constitutionality of Florida’s DUI laws, according to News4Jax. The Supreme Court was ruling on the constitutionality of warrantless breath and blood tests for alcohol content. While the Supreme Court ruled that warrantless breath tests are constitutional, it also ruled that police need to obtain a warrant if they want to withdraw a blood sample from a suspect. The ruling throws the constitutionality of some of Florida’s DUI laws into doubt.

Warrantless searches

The Supreme Court was tasked with deciding whether a person could be charged with a criminal offense if they refuse to provide a blood or breath test to measure alcohol in their systems. The law criminalizing such refusal was challenged as being unconstitutional because it did not require police to obtain a search warrant in order to withdraw the blood and breath samples.

The court’s ruling was somewhat mixed on the issue. While the court did find that warrantless breath tests were constitutional, the same could not be said for blood withdrawals. The top court determined that because blood withdrawals are far more invasive than breath tests and because they leave the government in possession of a person’s biological sample, that such tests should require a search warrant. As such, criminalizing the refusal of a blood withdrawal was determined to be unconstitutional.

Impact on Florida

The ruling has a significant impact on Florida’s DUI laws in a number of ways. For one, Florida’s criminalization of refusing a breath test had already been challenged on constitutional grounds. That challenge was supposed to be heard by the Florida Supreme Court later this year, although whether that case will actually go ahead now is unclear.

However, as FOX 13 News points out, Florida’s DUI laws also criminalize the refusal to provide a blood or urine sample for alcohol testing. While the U.S. Supreme Court did not rule on urine tests, it was clear that blood tests do require a warrant, suggesting some of Florida’s DUI laws are unconstitutional. Complicating the matter even further is that many of Florida’s DUI laws are misdemeanors and police, under Florida law, are already prohibited from obtaining search warrants for misdemeanor charges. In other words, the Supreme Court ruling suggests that lawmakers in Florida are going to have to consider seriously revising the state’s DUI laws.

Criminal defense

As the above article shows, DUI laws in Florida are constantly evolving. For anyone who has been charged with DUI, it is important to get legal help right away. A criminal defense attorney can help those who are facing drunk driving-related charges with their case, including how to respond to the charges and how best to protect their rights and freedoms moving forward.

Recent Criminal
Case Results

Grand Theft ($300-$5000)

Nolle Prosequi-Case Dropped

CT-Driving Under the Influence Car (M1)

Nolle Prosequi - Case Dropped

CT- Driving under the influence car

Nolle Prosequi - Case Dropped

Grand Theft Third Degree

Adjudicated Guilty; One day jail/one day time serve; Restitution fees; Court Cost

Petit Theft < 300

We negotiated an agreement that entailed the State dropping the charge after our client completed a Pre-Trial Diversion Program. The Charge was dropped via a Nolle Prosequi.

Unlawful Speeding

Withhold of Adjudication; No points on license; Paid fine and clerk cost; 8 hour aggressive driver class; 90 days to satisfy fine and class

Shoot/Throw Missile Into Dwell/Struct/Veh; Child Abuse; Criminal Mischief; Battery (Domestic Violence)

No Information Notice - Charges Dropped

Attach Tag/Lic Plate To Unassigned Vehicle (M2)

Nolle Prosequi - Case Dropped

DUI with Minor In Car or BAL of .20 or Higher

Pled No Contest, 1 Year Probation, 10 day Car Impound, Community Service

Motion to Modify Probation

Motion Granted in 48 hours

Petit Theft

Adjudication Withheld, 4 Months probation, Costs/Fines, Impulse Control Class

Petit Theft of $100 or MORE (M1)

Nolle Prosequi

Refuse To Submit To DUI Test (M1)

Case Dropped

Battery on Law Enforcement Officer (F3); Disorderly Conduct (M2)

Nolle Prosequi - Case Dropped


Charges Dropped

Scheme to Defraud(F3); Grand Theft(F3)

Motion to Terminate Probation Granted

Unlawful Speed


Failed to Yield at Intersection

Not Guilty

Leave Scene Of A Crash W/Property Damage (M2)

Case Dropped

Motion to Modify and Impose a Withhold of Adjudication


Attempted Burglary of a Conveyance

Charges dropped

Possession of Cannabis (less than 20 grams)

Charges dropped


Reduced to reckless driving

Possession of Alcohol Under the Age of 21

Charges dropped

Driving Under the Influence

Reduced to Reckless Driving

Violation of Probation

Case Dismissed

More Cases

Recent Personal
Injury Settlements


Scooter Accident


Car Accident


Car Accident


Government Liability Case


Back Injury

More Settlements